Do You Still Need a Supreme Court of Canada Agent?

The short answer is no. But there are still very good reasons to have one. For many years, lawyers practising outside the National Capital Region were required to retain an Ottawa agent when conducting business with the Registry and appearing before the Supreme Court of Canada. Changes to the Rules of the Supreme Court of Canada have removed the requirement to appoint an agent. Counsel can now manage their own filings and communications with the Court regardless of where they practise. The disappearance of the formal requirement, however, has not eliminated the value an experienced Supreme Court agent can bring to a case.

Supreme Court procedure is its own practice

A case before the Supreme Court of Canada is not just another appeal. The Court has its own Rules, filing requirements, deadlines and practices governing everything from applications for leave to appeal and interventions to appeals, motions and the preparation of records, factums and other materials.

 

Counsel who practise before the Court infrequently may therefore find themselves navigating unfamiliar procedural requirements at the same time that they are preparing a case of exceptional importance to their client.

 

An experienced Supreme Court agent deals with these requirements regularly. An agent can review materials for compliance, identify procedural issues before they become filing problems, coordinate service and filing, and communicate with the Registry when questions arise.

 

That experience provides an additional layer of quality control at a stage of litigation where there is little room for avoidable error.

Electronic filing has not eliminated the procedural burden

The Court's move toward electronic filing has made it easier for counsel across Canada to file documents directly. It has not, however, made Supreme Court procedure automatic.

 

Electronic filing does not itself constitute service on the other parties, and the Rules continue to impose requirements concerning the filing and preparation of Court materials. Deadlines remain important, and technical difficulties do not necessarily excuse a late filing.

 

Having someone who works regularly with the Court's filing practices can therefore be valuable even when there is no geographical reason to retain an Ottawa lawyer.

Agents are more than a filing service

The best Supreme Court agency relationships go beyond submitting documents to the Registry.

An experienced agent can provide a second set of eyes on a leave application, response, factum or other Court document. The agent can flag technical problems, assist with procedural questions and help counsel anticipate the practical steps that will arise as the proceeding moves forward.

That role can extend further, if counsel wishes. Agents like me can assist with legal research, editing and written advocacy, identifying the issues most likely to matter to the Court, and refining the presentation of the case. 

This can be particularly valuable at the leave stage. Applications for leave to appeal are not simply exercises in demonstrating that a lower court made an error. They require counsel to explain why the proposed appeal raises an issue warranting the attention of Canada's highest court. Agents can bring a useful outside perspective to that task.

Let counsel focus on the case

There is also a straightforward benefit.

 

Supreme Court litigation generates a considerable amount of procedural and administrative work. Time spent determining filing requirements, preparing materials for submission, arranging service and corresponding with the Registry is time that lead counsel cannot spend refining the client's substantive case.

 

Delegating that work to an experienced agent allows counsel to concentrate on what matters most: the theory of the case, the written argument and, where leave is granted, preparation for the hearing.

No longer mandatory, still valuable

The fact that an agent is no longer required should not be confused with the proposition that an agent is no longer useful.

 

For counsel who practise regularly before the Supreme Court, handling every aspect of a proceeding internally may make sense. For lawyers who appear before the Court less frequently, however, retaining an experienced Supreme Court agent can offer procedural expertise, another level of quality control and the benefit of regular familiarity with the Court and its practices.

The Rules may no longer require an agent. In the right case, having one can still make the Supreme Court process considerably easier.

If you have questions about agency services - please feel free to reach out to me.

 

Previous
Previous

Protecting Your Identity and Your Wishes: Why Advance Care Planning Matters for Trans People.